Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Gaming > Debate > Re: GM-controll...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 66 of 108 Topic 327 of 369
Post > Topic >>

Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points

by gleichman <fox1_217@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Aug 8, 2007 at 07:58 AM

On Aug 7, 7:56 pm, Peter Knutsen <pe...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
> > I was completely taken back by this as well. It seemed very out of
> > character.
>
> It still seems to me that you, and others in this thread, are
> overlooking a crucial factor of the Bad Luck mechaic: That it is
> extremely regulated, and that Bad Luck points are partitioned to each
> character.

Not so much overlooking as... unimpressed I supposed. It strikes me
the same as someone saying "I limit my adultery to only once a year".

One of Mary's better posts in this group was the one that stated that
if you don't want something in the game, don't allow it at all.
Attempting to control it by making it rare, difficult, etc is doomed
to failure as players/GM will just take the extra effort to make best
use of it even so.

So in this line, this strikes me as a new turn for you.
 




 108 Posts in Topic:
GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-07-11 14:21:46 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Simon Smith <simon_smi  2007-07-11 14:20:24 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-07-21 15:47:07 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-21 09:47:26 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-07-22 23:10:03 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-23 08:57:38 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 03:18:15 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-11 06:42:28 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-07-18 05:45:53 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-07-21 16:00:28 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-21 10:08:31 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 03:31:12 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Simon Smith <simon_smi  2007-07-22 01:53:51 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-07-23 00:43:30 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-23 08:37:00 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Simon Smith <simon_smi  2007-07-23 15:42:04 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-07-23 20:59:49 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 03:44:19 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Simon Smith <simon_smi  2007-07-28 01:57:04 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-27 23:10:37 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-24 07:05:37 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-07-26 00:33:31 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-26 06:15:51 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-07-26 07:45:47 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
David Alex Lamb <dalam  2007-07-28 11:10:12 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-28 11:10:00 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-26 06:23:09 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Beowulf Bolt <abd.al-h  2007-07-26 20:40:54 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-27 08:11:21 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Irina Rempt <irina@[EM  2007-07-27 17:19:15 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-27 09:28:44 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Irina Rempt <irina@[EM  2007-07-27 21:15:11 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
David Alex Lamb <dalam  2007-07-28 11:20:56 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-28 11:18:40 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-07-28 13:13:47 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-17 01:33:44 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
David Alex Lamb <dalam  2007-09-01 23:41:42 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-10 06:33:21 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Beowulf Bolt <abd.al-h  2007-07-27 16:41:41 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-27 09:53:31 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-27 13:00:05 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
David Alex Lamb <dalam  2007-07-28 11:23:22 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-28 11:04:34 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Beowulf Bolt <abd.al-h  2007-07-27 23:26:38 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-27 18:39:13 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Beowulf Bolt <abd.al-h  2007-07-28 19:59:15 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-28 15:10:43 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Beowulf Bolt <abd.al-h  2007-07-30 15:13:19 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-30 08:23:21 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
George W Harris <gharr  2007-07-30 16:41:39 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-06 13:32:54 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-08-07 07:05:26 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 02:56:03 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-08-07 09:06:48 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 02:53:14 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-06 15:09:40 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-08-07 07:14:15 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 02:53:04 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-07 07:17:09 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-07 07:55:13 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-07 10:05:15 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-07 11:02:47 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-10 05:49:07 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-08 07:51:01 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-11 05:44:08 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-08 07:58:18 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-11 05:51:00 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-08-13 18:06:48 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:11:12 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
David Alex Lamb <dalam  2007-09-02 00:04:43 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-08 07:59:29 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-11 05:51:32 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-08-13 18:09:57 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:12:19 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-08 08:07:14 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-08 09:34:03 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-11 06:06:26 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-09 17:10:12 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-10 06:29:40 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-11 06:13:54 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-10 06:35:07 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-10 09:54:54 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-11 12:43:57 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-08-11 12:50:32 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-08-13 18:19:19 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-14 18:40:53 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:19:57 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:02:21 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-09-24 00:29:50 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-12 16:18:23 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:09:04 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-14 11:03:42 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-14 20:20:53 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-14 12:42:53 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
John Morrow <morrow@[E  2007-08-15 00:18:41 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-15 16:29:16 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:20:46 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-15 07:58:26 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
John Morrow <morrow@[E  2007-08-15 23:38:01 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-17 03:39:43 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
arromdee@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2007-08-17 21:12:54 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-16 06:38:56 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-17 06:04:38 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-17 20:30:09 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-17 12:36:34 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-09-19 08:21:38 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-09-19 08:22:57 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-09-19 08:34:53 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sat Jul 26 11:24:25 CDT 2008.