Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points

Erol K. Bayburt responds to Brian Gleichman:

  2. If you find it "distasteful" to even talk about
  such systems, then WHY ARE YOUR HERE???

Possibly because he's trying to be helpful?  Brian knows a fair amount
about firearms, and Peter seems interested in the information.

Alternatively, perhaps he wants to understand the point of view
better, even if he finds it distasteful.  I must confess to a certain
degree of puzzlement as to why Peter, who has generally seemed to
dislike systems relying on gamesmaster judgement in the past, would
suggest such a system now.

By the way, having reread the thread in chronological order today,
this appears to me to be the first comment addressed to the author (ad
hominem) rather than to the subject of discussion.  I thought that
might be of interest to posters who started discussing personalities
later in the thread.

Warren J. Dew