Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Gaming > Debate > Re: GM-controll...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 8 of 108 Topic 327 of 369
Post > Topic >>

Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points

by gleichman <fox1_217@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Jul 11, 2007 at 06:42 AM

On Jul 11, 7:21 am, Peter Knutsen <p...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
> It's also idiotic to
> assume that a character's skill at *shooting* a weapon affects the
> chance of a jam.

Not completely.

Not holding a recoil operated weapon correctly for example can vastily
increase the chance of jamming depending upon the exact weapon and
details. And often skill in the weapon also reflects proper
maintainance and ammo selection both of which can greatly influence
matters. Each firearm has it's own quirks, and knowledge of them helps
one avoid them.

However your percentages are really out whack with respect to jam
chances, so it would be a exceedingly poor method in any event. Of
course I wouldn't touch your dice mechanic with a ten-foot pole in the
first place, but it's your game.


> The GM gets 6 weekly Bad Luck points for each PC, plus a further 6
> monthly Bad Luck Points for each PC.


The last thing I'd want as either a GM or a player is a game mechanic
that specifically requires the GM decide when and how to screw his
players. I'm sure there's a style of play where this is accepted and
expected, but it's a very alien one to me. Fumble mechanics and the
like are generally accepted because they take the matter out of the
GM's hands, so you're bucking gaming nature here. Which is something
you seem to enjoy doing.
 




 108 Posts in Topic:
GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-07-11 14:21:46 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Simon Smith <simon_smi  2007-07-11 14:20:24 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-07-21 15:47:07 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-21 09:47:26 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-07-22 23:10:03 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-23 08:57:38 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 03:18:15 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-11 06:42:28 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-07-18 05:45:53 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-07-21 16:00:28 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-21 10:08:31 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 03:31:12 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Simon Smith <simon_smi  2007-07-22 01:53:51 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-07-23 00:43:30 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-23 08:37:00 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Simon Smith <simon_smi  2007-07-23 15:42:04 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-07-23 20:59:49 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 03:44:19 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Simon Smith <simon_smi  2007-07-28 01:57:04 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-27 23:10:37 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-24 07:05:37 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-07-26 00:33:31 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-26 06:15:51 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-07-26 07:45:47 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
David Alex Lamb <dalam  2007-07-28 11:10:12 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-28 11:10:00 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-26 06:23:09 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Beowulf Bolt <abd.al-h  2007-07-26 20:40:54 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-27 08:11:21 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Irina Rempt <irina@[EM  2007-07-27 17:19:15 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-27 09:28:44 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Irina Rempt <irina@[EM  2007-07-27 21:15:11 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
David Alex Lamb <dalam  2007-07-28 11:20:56 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-28 11:18:40 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-07-28 13:13:47 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-17 01:33:44 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
David Alex Lamb <dalam  2007-09-01 23:41:42 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-10 06:33:21 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Beowulf Bolt <abd.al-h  2007-07-27 16:41:41 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-27 09:53:31 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-27 13:00:05 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
David Alex Lamb <dalam  2007-07-28 11:23:22 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-28 11:04:34 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Beowulf Bolt <abd.al-h  2007-07-27 23:26:38 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-27 18:39:13 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Beowulf Bolt <abd.al-h  2007-07-28 19:59:15 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-07-28 15:10:43 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Beowulf Bolt <abd.al-h  2007-07-30 15:13:19 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-07-30 08:23:21 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
George W Harris <gharr  2007-07-30 16:41:39 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-06 13:32:54 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-08-07 07:05:26 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 02:56:03 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-08-07 09:06:48 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 02:53:14 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-06 15:09:40 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-08-07 07:14:15 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-08 02:53:04 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-07 07:17:09 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-07 07:55:13 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-07 10:05:15 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-07 11:02:47 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-10 05:49:07 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-08 07:51:01 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-11 05:44:08 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-08 07:58:18 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-11 05:51:00 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-08-13 18:06:48 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:11:12 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
David Alex Lamb <dalam  2007-09-02 00:04:43 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-08 07:59:29 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-11 05:51:32 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-08-13 18:09:57 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:12:19 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-08 08:07:14 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-08 09:34:03 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-11 06:06:26 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-09 17:10:12 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-10 06:29:40 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-08-11 06:13:54 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-10 06:35:07 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-10 09:54:54 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-11 12:43:57 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Erol K. Bayburt <ErolB  2007-08-11 12:50:32 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
"gleichman" <  2007-08-13 18:19:19 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-14 18:40:53 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:19:57 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:02:21 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-09-24 00:29:50 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
psychohist <psychohist  2007-08-12 16:18:23 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:09:04 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-14 11:03:42 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-14 20:20:53 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-14 12:42:53 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
John Morrow <morrow@[E  2007-08-15 00:18:41 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-15 16:29:16 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Peter Knutsen <peter@[  2007-09-19 01:20:46 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-15 07:58:26 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
John Morrow <morrow@[E  2007-08-15 23:38:01 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-17 03:39:43 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
arromdee@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2007-08-17 21:12:54 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-16 06:38:56 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-17 06:04:38 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
Russell Wallace <russe  2007-08-17 20:30:09 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-08-17 12:36:34 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-09-19 08:21:38 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-09-19 08:22:57 
Re: GM-controlled Bad Luck points
gleichman <fox1_217@[E  2007-09-19 08:34:53 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sat Jul 26 4:16:02 CDT 2008.