Talk About Network



Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Gaming > Diplomacy > Comments on EOG...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 1 of 5 Topic 1357 of 1373
Post > Topic >>

Comments on EOG...

by Chris Babcock <cbabcock@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Apr 9, 2008 at 07:43 PM

A no press game ends in a Turkish solo in F1925M. Here are the maps:

http://www.floc.net/observer.py?judge=USAK&game=fge00003&page=game

This is England's End of Game statement: 

----------------

The last move of the game featured the most
dishonorable win I have ever witnessed. Turkey, shame
on you! After seeing what France did to you in Spring
1922 (move in on your supply centers when you had
retreated, clearly signaling a 3-way draw), you should
have known better how that is not the way to win!

I could have won the game had I moved in on you right
then, but decided that this would have been
dishonorable. Instead, I chose and succeeded in
punishing France for the unsportsmanlike conduct
(while signaling my desire for a TWO-WAY draw by
withdrawing my forces from Russia, exactly the same
method you had chosen). What makes me upset isn't that
I lost the chance to win the game, but that of all
possible opponents, you, the victim of unsportsmanlike
conduct yourself in the same game, pulled the same
cheap stunt yourself. A win should be the result of
brilliant play or an opponent's mistake, and not
moving in on a player when he is unfairly down. What
you did was like a mugging victim ending up mugging
the same person who defended her. And I know you won't
get this, but even in Diplomacy where lying and
stabbing are part of the game, there is a place for
honor.

 I had a lot of respect for the way you had played
until the last move. A two-way draw in this game would
have been one of the most beautiful results in all the
games I have played (and I've won many, honorably).
But instead, you blew it! Your last move reminds me of
watching a graceful athlete win a game with wonderful
speed and agility, but then celebrating it with the
ugliest and most desperate taunting of his opponent.

----------------

Comments? Shame on Turkey, shame on England or shame on me? ;-) 

Chris




 5 Posts in Topic:
Comments on EOG...
Chris Babcock <cbabcoc  2008-04-09 19:43:35 
Re: Comments on EOG...
Jim Burgess <burgess@[  2008-04-10 03:22:30 
Re: Comments on EOG...
"David E. Cohen"  2008-04-10 07:43:24 
Re: Comments on EOG...
Eric Hunter <hunter90@  2008-04-09 23:47:39 
Re: Comments on EOG...
Dougray30 <dougray30@[  2008-04-10 04:12:38 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Tue May 13 10:48:36 CDT 2008.