Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Gaming > Chinese chess (Xiangqi) > Re: The social ...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 9 of 12 Topic 416 of 459
Post > Topic >>

Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi

by "wuolong@[EMAIL PROTECTED] " <wuolong@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Oct 16, 2007 at 04:48 AM

On Sep 28, 3:24 pm, "Josef Pieper" <n...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
> Is Go or Xiangqi or both promoted in Chinese schools?

Definitely.  Much more so than Chess in the US.

> What is the status of Go relative to Xiangqi in Chinese culture?

I agree with the *****sment that Go is considered more elite.  It is a
more abstract game
and is more agreeable to Chinese philosophy.  Legend has it that
Xiangqi was invented by
General Han Xin to train his soldliers, while Go was more ancient,
invented by Shun (legendary
'emperor', one of the three 'wise' model leaders) for educating his
son, to be wise.

Another factor is that Go has more international competition (Japan,
Korea) and Go player Nie
Weiping was considered national hero for defeating top Japanese
players.  (Same thing with Xie Jun
for winning Women's Chess Champion****p).  For Xiangqi, there is not as
much national media attention
(and promotion).

> A quick search on ebay shows Xiangqi sets made of plastic or cheap wood
with
> paper boards are quite inexpensive.  Go equipment on ebay or from, say,
> Yellow Mountain Im****ts, can be quite expensive.  Can this difference
> between the two games be taken as a sign of their different social
status?

Perhaps. Even in national competitions, the Xianqqi sets used are
quite plain.  I guess in a way the goal of
Xiangqi is to kill, while the goal of Weiqi is to enjoy.

I'm from China, BTW.

wuolong
 




 12 Posts in Topic:
The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Josef Pieper"   2007-09-28 16:24:00 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
royls@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2007-09-28 20:39:30 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
Jeff Nowakowski <jeffn  2007-09-28 18:37:28 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Josef Pieper"   2007-09-28 19:32:04 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Dirt At Your Face&q  2007-09-29 14:18:08 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Dirt At Your Face&q  2007-09-29 14:21:54 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
Jeff Nowakowski <jeffn  2007-09-29 22:31:22 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
Max <maxdwolf@[EMAIL P  2007-10-05 14:01:32 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"wuolong@[EMAIL PROT  2007-10-16 04:48:54 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Josef Pieper"   2007-10-18 20:13:21 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Josef Pieper"   2007-10-16 13:29:54 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Josef Pieper"   2007-10-17 19:21:36 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sat Jul 26 10:50:09 CDT 2008.