Talk About Network



Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Gaming > Chinese chess (Xiangqi) > The social stat...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 1 of 12 Topic 416 of 454
Post > Topic >>

The social status of Go and Xiangqi

by "Josef Pieper" <nemo@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sep 28, 2007 at 04:24 PM

I am very interested in the cultural status of Go and Xiangqi in China. In 
the US (where I live) international chess is being promoted in many
schools. 
There's a body of research that indicates that students improve greatly 
academically when they study and play chess. Is Go or Xiangqi or both 
promoted in Chinese schools?

What is the status of Go relative to Xiangqi in Chinese culture? In the 
West, generally speaking, international chess is considered an 
"intellectual" pursuit and it's players are considered highly intelligent.

There's no money in it if you play in the US (I hear it's better in
Europe), 
but it's a respectable game.

From what I've read, Xiangqi appears to be a game for the "masses." For 
example, Sam Sloan,  in "Chinese Chess for Beginners" says that nearly 
everyone in China knows how to play xiangqi."

In contrast, in "Games Ancient and Oriental", Edward Falkener suggests
that 
Go in Chinese culture is considered a game for the "elite." A person who 
seriously plays Go would be expected to be a person of accomplishment and 
refinement in China.

A quick search on ebay shows Xiangqi sets made of plastic or cheap wood
with 
paper boards are quite inexpensive.  Go equipment on ebay or from, say, 
Yellow Mountain Imports, can be quite expensive.  Can this difference 
between the two games be taken as a sign of their different social status?

I'd be grateful if you could provide any assistance or insight to my 
research.



Thank you.



-- 
Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com




 12 Posts in Topic:
The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Josef Pieper"   2007-09-28 16:24:00 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
royls@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2007-09-28 20:39:30 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
Jeff Nowakowski <jeffn  2007-09-28 18:37:28 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Josef Pieper"   2007-09-28 19:32:04 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Dirt At Your Face&q  2007-09-29 14:18:08 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Dirt At Your Face&q  2007-09-29 14:21:54 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
Jeff Nowakowski <jeffn  2007-09-29 22:31:22 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
Max <maxdwolf@[EMAIL P  2007-10-05 14:01:32 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"wuolong@[EMAIL PROT  2007-10-16 04:48:54 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Josef Pieper"   2007-10-18 20:13:21 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Josef Pieper"   2007-10-16 13:29:54 
Re: The social status of Go and Xiangqi
"Josef Pieper"   2007-10-17 19:21:36 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Fri May 16 7:30:12 CDT 2008.