Re: some bidding situations

cbfalconer@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 writes:
>Lone Locust of the Apocalypse wrote:
>> ted <morristed@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> writes:
>>>> hand #4: vul vs not
>>>>
>>>> AKQ2 64 T93 KQJ6
>>>> 765 AQJ9 765 AT8
>>>>
>>>> East deals and opens 1D (could be short).  Opps are silent
>>>> thereafter.  Suggest an auction.
>>>
>>> (1D) 1S (P)  2S
>>> (P)   3C  (P)  4S
>>> all pass?
>>> Did you necessarily expect an auction for a making contract?
>> 
>> No, of course not.  Although to clarify, the upper hand is North,
>> so it is the lower hand that has direct action over the 1D opener.
>
>Oh?  You mean it overcalled 1D with 1S holding 765 in spades?

No.  You appear to be confusing the order or semantics of the messages.

1. I posted hands and asked for a suggested auction.
2. Ted provided one.
3. I pointed out he'd gotten the orientation of the hands wrong.