Re: S:JT H:KT63 D:A72 C:9764, ok, what happens next...?

On Apr 30, 7:50 pm, vspo...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 wrote:
> On Apr 28, 10:33 am, Histriadogsilver <andjelka.rich...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> wrote:
>
>
>
> > West   North   East   South
> >  ------      1H       p        2H ( constructive raise otherwise 1N F1
> > with subsequent 2H rebid)
> >    p        2S!!      p         ?
>
> > The bid of 2S!! is showing a shortness somewhere. What do you do now?
>
> > A.) You ask with 2N since you are interested in knowing in which suit
> > the shortness is
> > B.) You deny the invitation with 3H since your hand has minimum values
> > for the shown raise
> > C.) You just blast to game
>
> > I'll show you partner's hand later.
>
> > Boris
>
> Opener got lucky.  No way Axxx QJ9xx KQx x is worth an invite over
> a constructive 2H raise.  The raise doesn't promise 4 hearts, does it?
> Responder could have a max and 2H is still the limit for the two
> hands.
> Qx KTx xxxx Axxx.  Some may even go down in 2H.

Right, no one can expect a 2H contract with an eight card fit, 21 hcps
and a side singleton to make, let alone 3H on a finesse. And say the
discussion ended on why on earth someone needs to know the location of
the damned singleton when bidding game is so right.

Boris