Re: I'll take "reconstruct the hands" for $1 million, Alex!

David Stevenson wrote:
>  wrote
>> You hear this uncontested auction at IMPs:
>>
>> Opener     Responder
>> 1c             1s
>> 2d             2s
>> 3h             4c
>> 4s              p
>>
>> Approximate opener's hand and responder's hand.
> 
> Qx           KJ9xx
> Jx           xxx
> AKQx         xx
> AKxxx        Qxx
> 



I approve o opener's bidding, but not responder's.   Over 2D responder 
should just bid 3 Clubs.  If opener bid 3H, then 3 Spades is justified. 
  But surely responder should be willing to count on pener bidding 
spades wih three of them over 3 clubs.

Bob