by Stephen Fischer <stephendotfischer@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
Apr 26, 2008 at 03:29 PM
Charles Brenner wrote:
> On Apr 25, 1:23 am, Jan Veerbeek <jbveerb...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>> IMP's
>> East/ all white
>>
>> Your hand:
>> S A K 10 9 8 5 2
>> H K J 6 5
>> D 2
>> C Q
>>
>> The bidding:
>> West North East South
>> -- --- 1C* pass
>> 1H** ?
>>
>> 1C = 2+ card C, no 5-card major, 11-19 HCP
>> 1H = Transfer Walsh, 4+card S and 6+ HCP
>>
>> Well, what will be Your action and why?
>>
>> Jan Veerbeek
>
> 3S for me. I think 1S is outlandish -- why will partner think it shows
> spades?
>
> Charles
Presumably because you discussed it before the round.
A constructive 1S rather than a preemptive 2S for me.
