Re: How many questions about an opening bid before it's UI?

On Apr 25, 11:52 am, Michael Angelo Ravera <marav...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
wrote:

> > If you're assuming that the only reasons for asking these kinds of
> > questions are that LHO is either considering taking some immediate
> > action, or is unethically trying to convey information about clubs to
> > his partner, I think your assumption is dead wrong.  Maybe that's the
> > basis for the disagreement we're having.  I've been trying to figure
> > out why you are so intractably convinced that it's "obvious" that the
> > questioner is suggesting something in clubs (and similarly in your
> > example involving a 2C opening, which I think you're wrong about
> > also), when nobody agrees with you and about a dozen other people here
> > believe it's clear that LHO is *not* suggesting anything about clubs.
> > The only things I can think of are either your conclusion is based on
> > an assumption that the rest of us believe is incorrect, or that you've
> > been affected by some bad past experiences involving unethical
> > opponents.  Or (as some of us have suggested) that there's information
> > about what happened at the table that you can't tell us, like body
> > language.  But other than those, I'm at a loss.
>
> I _never_ suggested that the _questions_ were unethical!

Please read carefully.  I was talking about the possibility that you
ran into some unethical behavior in the past.

                                  -- Adam