Re: How many questions about an opening bid before it's UI?

[...]
>he questions (or I wouldn't have called the TD). The question is
>whether my RHO would have lead a club anyway and thus didn't have any
l>ogical alternative. 

According to Law 16 this is not the correct rationale. However,
it is the question a reasonable person would ask.

>The TD ruled that he would have led a club
>anyway.

This director is disregarding the laws and exposing herself
to the wrath of David Stevenson.
 
> I believe that I later determined that I agreed with her.

>Opponents are not required to make a dumbass lead just because they
>have UI,

Yes they are, and this is why Law 16 is idiotic.

[...]